Evaluation of Publicly Accessible Nature-Based Solutions Databases as Sources for Evidence of Effectiveness

Posted by
CAKE TeamPublished
Abstract
Nature-based solutions (NBS) are “actions to protect, sustainably manage, or restore natural or modified ecosystems to address societal challenges, simultaneously providing benefits for people and the environment.”
They present opportunities to tackle both the climate and biodiversity crises simultaneously by supporting carbon sequestration by ecosystems, enhancing community resilience to climate hazards, and providing high-quality habitats for diverse species. However, uncertainty around the performance and reliability of NBS continues to be raised by engineers, local decision-makers, grant-makers, and the insurance industry as an obstacle for widespread implementation of NBS at scale. This uncertainty indicates the need for comprehensive and accessible data on NBS projects and outcomes that could be used to develop engineering standards, assess projects’ cost-benefit ratio, and incorporate NBS into insurance premium pricing.
A first step in addressing this challenge is understanding where different types of NBS projects have been implemented, what their intended outcomes were, how those projects have performed, and what factors have influenced their performance. This report evaluates the NBS data currently available through publicly available databases relative to the information needs described above. In total, 27 databases with publicly available, structured information on NBS research studies (6 databases) or individual projects (21 databases) were assessed for their utility as well as geographic and topical coverage.
The project objectives were to achieve the following:
- Understand the information currently available on NBS performance through research literature and project-level reporting in existing databases
- Evaluate the type and utility of information contained in each identified database
- Assess the coverage of NBS information available in the identified databases in terms of geography and NBS types
- Identify gaps in NBS database coverage and utility